The United States has hidden gems scattered across its waters, and many people don’t realize just how many amazing islands exist right here at home. Beyond the famous spots like Hawaii and Martha’s Vineyard, countless lesser-known islands offer peaceful beaches, historic lighthouses, and untouched nature — all without needing a passport or dealing with currency exchange.
These secret island getaways give visitors a chance to escape everyday life without leaving North America. Some of these spots feel completely remote despite being just a short ferry ride from major cities, while others require a bit more planning but reward travelers with rare wildlife sightings and pristine landscapes that few get to experience.
Block Island, Rhode Island
Located off the coast of Rhode Island, Block Island charms visitors with its Victorian architecture and 17 miles of pristine beaches. The island’s two historic lighthouses tell stories of maritime history, while the rolling green hills filled with stone walls showcase New England’s farming heritage. Walking and biking trails crisscross the island, leading to dramatic bluffs and hidden coves. The vibrant town center offers local seafood restaurants and unique shops housed in classic buildings.
Kelleys Island, Ohio
This Lake Erie island surprises visitors with its impressive glacial grooves, carved into limestone bedrock during the ice age. The island maintains a slow-paced atmosphere with its small year-round population and focus on nature preservation. Visitors can explore ancient Native American petroglyphs, hunt for rare fossils, or watch migrating butterflies in the fall. The crystal-clear waters around the island are perfect for swimming and kayaking.
Cumberland Island, Georgia
Wild horses roam freely on this untamed barrier island, sharing space with ancient live oak trees draped in Spanish moss. The crumbling ruins of Carnegie family mansions add a layer of mystery to the pristine beaches and maritime forests. Nature enthusiasts can spot armadillos, turkeys, and countless shore birds while hiking the island’s extensive trail system. The island’s remote location and limited ferry service help maintain its untouched character.
Apostle Islands, Wisconsin
These 21 islands in Lake Superior hold some of America’s most beautiful sea caves and lighthouses. Winter transforms the caves into ice palaces, while summer brings opportunities for kayaking through crystal-clear waters and natural stone arches. The islands contain more historic lighthouses than any other location in the National Park Service. Camping on the outer islands offers unmatched stargazing experiences away from city lights.
Channel Islands, California
Often called North America’s Galapagos, these five islands host unique species found nowhere else on Earth. The surrounding waters teem with whales, dolphins, and colorful fish visible through kelp forests. Visitors can explore ancient Chumash Native American sites and see rare island foxes in their natural habitat. The islands offer world-class snorkeling and diving opportunities in protected marine sanctuaries.
San Juan Islands, Washington
Located in the Salish Sea, these islands offer some of the best orca whale watching in the country. Each island has its own personality – Lopez is known for friendly cyclists, Orcas for its artist communities, and San Juan for its historic Friday Harbor. Visitors can kayak with seals, spot bald eagles, and enjoy fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants. The islands experience less rainfall than mainland Washington thanks to their location in the rain shadow of the Olympic Mountains.
Smith Island, Maryland
This unique Chesapeake Bay island maintains a rich culture dating back to the 1600s, complete with a distinct dialect found nowhere else in America. Famous for its multi-layered Smith Island cake and fresh seafood, the island offers visitors a glimpse into traditional watermen culture. Bird watchers flock here to spot rare waterfowl in the marshlands surrounding the three small communities. Rising sea levels make this cultural treasure even more special to visit while it still exists.
Monhegan Island, Maine
Artists have been drawn to this car-free island’s dramatic cliffs and quaint fishing village for over 100 years. The island’s 17 miles of hiking trails lead through spruce forests to stunning ocean vistas and hidden coves. Local fishermen still practice traditional lobstering methods, while residents maintain a close-knit year-round community. The island’s isolation has helped preserve its natural beauty and authentic New England character.
Tangier Island, Virginia
Often called the “soft crab capital of the world,” this unique Chesapeake Bay island seems frozen in time. Residents speak a distinctive dialect with roots in Colonial-era English, and most families have lived here for generations. Golf carts and bikes serve as the main transportation on the narrow streets between historic homes. The island’s seafood restaurants serve up the freshest crabs caught by local watermen each morning.
Daufuskie Island, South Carolina
This car-free island between Hilton Head and Savannah preserves its Gullah culture through artisan crafts and traditional foods. Historic buildings, including the First Union African Baptist Church, tell stories of the island’s rich history. Visitors can explore sandy lanes beneath ancient live oaks or learn about traditional sweetgrass basket weaving. Local restaurants serve authentic Lowcountry cuisine using recipes passed down through generations.
Isle Royale, Michigan
This remote national park in Lake Superior offers true wilderness experiences with wolf and moose populations, old-growth forests, and crystal-clear lakes. Backpackers can explore over 165 miles of hiking trails connecting historic lighthouses and abandoned copper mines. The island’s isolation creates unique opportunities to study predator-prey relationships in an undisturbed environment. Scuba divers explore numerous shipwrecks preserved in the cold lake waters.
Deer Isle, Maine
Connected to the mainland by a stunning suspension bridge, this working fishing village maintains authentic coastal Maine culture. The island hosts a thriving artist community alongside traditional lobstering families who have worked these waters for generations. Visitors can watch boatbuilders practice their craft or explore quiet coves in kayaks. The island’s granite quarries once provided stone for famous buildings, including the John F. Kennedy Memorial.
Little Palm Island, Florida Keys
This exclusive private island resort offers a taste of tropical luxury without leaving U.S. waters. Thatched-roof bungalows sit along white sand beaches where key deer sometimes visit from nearby refuges. The surrounding waters offer excellent opportunities for snorkeling and spotting dolphins, manatees, and tropical fish. Despite its upscale amenities, the island maintains a natural, Robinson Crusoe atmosphere with no phones or televisions in rooms.
16 Shows That Changed TV For The Worse
16 Shows That Changed TV For The Worse
16 Nations Where Visas Are Hardest to Get
16 Nations Where Visas Are Hardest to Get
10 Countries Where Millionaires Pay the Least Taxes
