When Americans visit grocery stores in Canada, they might notice some differences in the food products on the shelves. One major contrast is the list of ingredients – specifically, certain preservatives that are common in American foods but heavily restricted or banned in Canada. These differences stem from varying food safety regulations between the two countries, with Canada taking a more cautious approach to certain additives that American manufacturers use regularly.
Canada’s stricter regulations on these 14 food preservatives reflect a different philosophy about what chemicals are acceptable in our daily meals, even when their American neighbors continue to use them without restriction.
1. Brominated Vegetable Oil (BVO)
Many American citrus-flavored sodas and sports drinks contain brominated vegetable oil. This additive helps prevent the citrus flavor from separating and floating to the top of beverages. Canada banned BVO because it contains bromine, an element also found in flame retardants, which can build up in the body and potentially cause memory problems and skin conditions. Some American companies have recently begun removing BVO from their products after public pressure.
2. Potassium Bromate
Bakeries across America often use potassium bromate to strengthen dough and help bread rise higher. It’s particularly common in fast food buns, pizza dough, and some packaged breads in the US. Canada prohibits this additive because it’s potentially carcinogenic, meaning it might cause cancer when consumed in large amounts or over long periods. Studies have linked it to thyroid problems and kidney damage in laboratory animals.
3. Brominated Flour
Some specialty baking products in America still use brominated flour despite its decreasing popularity. This flour treatment process uses potassium bromate to strengthen the gluten network in dough and improve volume. Canada banned brominated flour completely, as the bromine residues in finished products raise the same health concerns as potassium bromate itself. Canadian bakers use alternative strengthening methods like ascorbic acid (vitamin C) and enzyme treatments instead.
4. Butylated Hydroxyanisole (BHA)
American cereals, potato chips, and chewing gum frequently contain BHA as a preservative that prevents oils from going rancid. While still permitted in the US, Canada has restricted its use because of potential endocrine disruption effects. The chemical has been classified as a possible human carcinogen by the International Agency for Research on Cancer. Canadian regulations require careful monitoring of BHA levels and prohibit its use in many products marketed to children.
5. Butylated Hydroxytoluene (BHT)
Snack foods throughout the United States often include butylated hydroxytoluene as an antioxidant preservative. It extends shelf life by preventing fats in cereals and packaged meats. Canada has stricter limits on BHT than the US because some studies suggest it may affect hormone levels and potentially cause liver enlargement. Many Canadian food manufacturers have voluntarily removed BHT from their products, replacing it with vitamin E or other natural alternatives.
6. Propyl Paraben
Baked goods in American stores frequently feature propyl paraben in their ingredient lists. This chemical helps prevent mold growth and extends shelf life in products with high sugar content. Canada limits propyl paraben much more strictly than the US due to research suggesting it may disrupt hormones, particularly estrogen. Scientists have raised concerns about its potential effects on reproductive health and early puberty in children.
7. Tertiary Butylhydroquinone (TBHQ)
Fast food chains in America rely on TBHQ as a synthetic preservative for many products. It’s particularly effective at preventing oxidation in oils and fats, which helps processed foods stay shelf-stable longer. Canada restricts TBHQ more heavily than the US because some studies link it to vision disturbances, liver enlargement, and possible DNA damage. The chemical is derived from petroleum and has been associated with nausea and vomiting when consumed in very high doses.
8. Sodium Nitrite
Processed meats sold in American supermarkets typically contain sodium nitrite. They help prevent bacterial growth, maintain color, and enhance flavor in cured meat products like hot dogs and bacon. Canada has stricter limits on these additives because when cooked at high temperatures, they can form nitrosamines, which are known carcinogens. Canadian regulations require lower maximum levels and mandate the addition of vitamin C, which helps prevent nitrosamine formation.
9. Yellow Dye #5 (Tartrazine)
Children’s products in the US often feature Yellow Dye #5 in their vibrant coloring. It creates bright yellow hues that make processed foods more visually appealing in candies and cereals. Canada requires special labeling for products containing Yellow Dye #5 because it has been linked to hyperactivity in sensitive children and allergic reactions in people with aspirin sensitivities. Many Canadian manufacturers have switched to natural alternatives like turmeric and beta-carotene.
10. Red Dye #40 (Allura Red)
Colorful treats lining American store shelves commonly contain Red Dye #40 as their primary coloring agent. This synthetic dye creates bright red colors that make products more attractive in candies and cereals marketed to children. Canada has stricter regulations on Red Dye #40 due to studies suggesting it may contribute to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in some children. Canadian food manufacturers often use beetroot extract or other natural colorings instead.
11. Recombinant Bovine Growth Hormone (rBGH)
Dairy farms across America frequently use rBGH, a synthetic hormone, to increase milk production in cows. It’s banned in Canada because of concerns about both animal welfare and potential human health effects. Canadian authorities cited studies showing increased infections in cows treated with rBGH, requiring more antibiotic use. They also noted potential links to increased insulin-like growth factor (IGF-1) in humans, which some research suggests may increase cancer risk.
12. Olestra (Olean)
Snack companies in the United States developed Olestra as a fat substitute for “fat-free” potato chips. It passes through the digestive system without being absorbed, allowing for the creation of fat-free products that still taste like their full-fat counterparts. Canada banned Olestra because it can cause uncomfortable digestive effects like abdominal cramping and loose stools. Even more concerning, Olestra prevents the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins and nutrients from other foods eaten at the same time.
13. Sulphites as Preservatives in Fresh Meat
Butcher shops in America can legally use sulphites in fresh meat to maintain a red color longer. Sulphites in meat can make older products appear fresher than they actually are, potentially misleading consumers about product quality. Canada banned this practice because it can trigger severe reactions in sensitive individuals, particularly those with asthma. Canadian regulations focus on preventing these reactions and ensuring that meat freshness is accurately represented.
14. Diphenylamine (DPA)
Apple producers in the US regularly apply diphenylamine to their fruit after harvest to prevent “storage scald.” It’s not technically a food additive but remains on the fruit as a residue that consumers ultimately ingest. Canada has much stricter limits on DPA residues because of concerns about its breakdown products, which may form carcinogens. Canadian apple growers must use alternative storage methods or different varieties that store well naturally without chemical treatment.
Related: The 15 Most Underrated Bands of the ’70s: Why Didn’t They Make It Big?
These 15 bands had it all—killer songwriting, amazing musicians, and unique sounds—but bad timing, record label problems, or just plain bad luck kept them from hitting the big time.
The 15 Most Underrated Bands of the ’70s: Why Didn’t They Make It Big?
14 Signs You’re Not Eating Enough Protein (And Delicious Ways to Add More)
There’s a world of tasty, protein-packed options waiting for you, whether you love a good steak or prefer keeping things plant-based with hearty beans and seasoned tofu.
14 Signs You’re Not Eating Enough Protein (And Delicious Ways to Add More)
