Making it big in music takes talent, timing, and a bit of luck. Some artists burst onto the scene with an amazing first song that captures everyone’s attention and becomes a massive hit. But for these musicians, that initial success became both a blessing and a burden — they spent their careers trying to create another song that would match their first breakthrough moment.
The following 14 artists showed incredible potential with their first releases, but despite their continued efforts and talent, they never quite reached the same heights again.
Lou Bega – Mambo No. 5
Lou Bega took the world by storm in 1999 with his catchy remake of a 1949 instrumental song. The upbeat dance track dominated radio stations and became a global phenomenon, selling millions of copies worldwide. After this massive success, Bega released several follow-up singles and albums, but none came close to matching the popularity of his debut hit. His later work mainly found success in German-speaking countries, where he continues to perform today.
Vanilla Ice – Ice Ice Baby
The 1990 hip-hop track that sampled Queen’s Under Pressure became a cultural phenomenon and made Vanilla Ice an overnight sensation. The song topped charts worldwide and made him the first white rapper to lead the Billboard Hot 100. His subsequent albums and singles failed to capture public interest, despite his attempts to reinvent his style. The pressure of following up on such a massive hit led to personal struggles and career challenges.
Right Said Fred – I’m Too Sexy
This British band struck gold with their 1991 dance-pop hit that poked fun at the fashion industry. The quirky song topped the charts in multiple countries and became a cultural reference that lives on today. The band continued making music and touring, releasing several albums throughout the decades. Despite creating other solid songs, nothing quite captured the public’s imagination like their first release.
Gotye – Somebody That I Used to Know
The 2011 breakup anthem featuring Kimbra became one of the most successful songs of the decade. The unique sound and emotional lyrics resonated with millions, earning multiple Grammy awards and billions of views online. After this enormous success, Gotye chose to step back from mainstream music, focusing on experimental projects and his original band. He has yet to release another solo album since his worldwide hit.
Dexys Midnight Runners – Come On Eileen
This 1982 Celtic-influenced pop song became a worldwide smash hit and won multiple awards. The band crafted a unique sound that blended traditional Irish instruments with modern pop sensibilities. Their later albums showed artistic growth and received critical praise, but commercial success remained elusive. The group disbanded and reformed several times, never recreating the magic of their signature song.
A-ha – Take On Me
The Norwegian band’s 1985 debut single combined an unforgettable melody with groundbreaking animation in its music video. The song reached number one in multiple countries and remains a beloved pop culture touchstone. A-ha continued making music and maintained popularity in Europe, particularly in their home country. However, their subsequent releases never achieved the same level of international recognition as their first hit.
Los del Río – Macarena
This Spanish duo created one of the biggest dance crazes of all time with their 1993 song. The Bayside Boys remix in 1995 turned it into a global phenomenon that spent 14 weeks at number one. Los del Río remained active in the Spanish music scene, releasing multiple albums. Despite their continued success in Spain, they never managed to create another international hit of similar magnitude.
Soft Cell – Tainted Love
The British duo’s 1981 cover of Gloria Jones’ soul song became an instant classic of the new wave era. Their electronic remake topped charts worldwide and helped define the synth-pop sound of the early 1980s. The band released several albums featuring creative and boundary-pushing music. Yet commercial success proved hard to find, and none of their other songs achieved the same level of recognition.
Norman Greenbaum – Spirit in the Sky
This 1969 rock song with its distinctive guitar sound and religious lyrics became a surprise hit. The track sold millions of copies and has been featured in countless movies and commercials over the decades. Greenbaum continued to write and record music after his success but never released another charting single. He focused on other ventures while his one-hit wonder continued to generate royalties.
Chesney Hawkes – The One and Only
This 1991 pop-rock song launched 19-year-old Hawkes to instant stardom in the UK and beyond. The track, written by Nik Kershaw, spent five weeks at number one in the UK and made Hawkes a teenage heartthrob. He continued releasing music and performing throughout the decades, trying different musical styles. Despite his ongoing career in entertainment, including acting and reality TV appearances, no other song reached the same level of success.
Bobby McFerrin – Don’t Worry, Be Happy
This 1988 Acappella song became a global hit with its simple message and memorable melody. McFerrin created the entire track using only his voice, winning multiple Grammy awards for his innovation. His career continued successfully in jazz and classical music as a conductor and performer. Despite his ongoing artistic achievements, none of his other works reached the mainstream success of his feel-good hit.
Eagle-Eye Cherry – Save Tonight
This 1997 folk-rock hit took over radio stations with its catchy acoustic guitar and heartfelt lyrics. The song reached top positions in multiple countries and earned heavy MTV rotation. Eagle-Eye Cherry, son of jazz musician Don Cherry, released several more albums throughout his career. Despite creating solid music that showed his songwriting talents, none of his later works captured the same widespread attention as his debut single.
Sir Mix-a-Lot – Baby Got Back
The 1992 hip-hop song became famous for its humorous lyrics and memorable music video about body positivity. The track won a Grammy and has become a permanent part of pop culture, referenced in countless movies and TV shows. Sir Mix-a-Lot continued making music and later moved into production and business ventures. Although he remained respected in the hip-hop community, his subsequent releases never achieved the same mainstream success.
House of Pain – Jump Around
The 1992 hip-hop anthem became a party staple with its high-energy beat and memorable horn sample. The song’s success helped establish Irish American hip-hop and developed the genre. The group released two more albums before breaking up in 1996. Member DJ Lethal found success with Limp Bizkit, while Everlast pursued a solo career, but neither reached the heights of their collective first hit.
15 Most Influential Men in Rock History
15 Most Influential Men in Rock History
13 Country Songs That Sparked Controversy
13 Country Songs That Sparked Controversy
19 Songs That Were Ahead of Their Time — And Flopped Initially
19 Songs That Were Ahead of Their Time — And Flopped Initially
