Catholicism is one of the world’s largest religions, with over a billion followers worldwide. Despite its long history and widespread presence, many misconceptions about Catholic beliefs persist. In this post, I’ll explore 18 common misconceptions about Catholic beliefs and practices.
Catholics worship Mary and the saints
Mary and the saints are highly respected in Catholicism, but they are not worshipped. Catholics believe in asking Mary and the saints to pray for them, similar to how someone might ask a friend for prayers. This practice is called intercession. Catholics believe that only God is worthy of worship, and they direct their prayers and worship to Him alone.
The Pope is infallible in everything he says
Papal infallibility is often misunderstood. It only applies to specific teachings on faith and morals, declared by the Pope to be held by the whole Church. This happens very rarely. The Pope is not considered infallible in daily life and most of his teachings. Catholics respect the Pope’s authority but understand that he, like all humans, can make mistakes in his personal opinions and actions.
Catholics believe good works alone can save them
Contrary to popular belief, Catholics do not think they can earn their way into heaven through good deeds alone. Catholic teaching emphasizes that salvation comes through God’s grace, which is a free gift. Good works are seen as a response to God’s love and a way to grow in faith, not as a way to earn salvation. Catholics believe in a balance of faith and works, with both playing important roles in the spiritual life.
The Catholic Church is against science
The Catholic Church has a long history of supporting scientific research and education. Many famous scientists throughout history were Catholic priests or members of religious orders. The Church teaches that faith and reason are compatible and that scientific discoveries can help us better understand God’s creation. While there have been conflicts between the Church and scientists in the past, today, the Church encourages scientific inquiry and sees it as complementary to faith.
Catholics can’t read the Bible on their own
Catholics are actually encouraged to read and study the Bible. The Church provides guidance and interpretation but doesn’t forbid personal Bible reading. In fact, Catholics are urged to read Scripture regularly as part of their spiritual growth. The Church offers Bible study programs and resources to help Catholics understand the Bible better. The idea that Catholics can’t read the Bible comes from a time when literacy was low and printed Bibles were scarce.
All priests must be celibate
While most Catholic priests in the Western Church practice celibacy, it’s not a doctrine of the faith. Eastern Catholic Churches, which are in full communion with Rome, allow married men to become priests. Additionally, some married Protestant clergy who convert to Catholicism can be ordained as priests. The practice of celibacy is a discipline that can be changed, not an unchangeable rule.
Catholics practice idol worship
The statues and images in Catholic churches are not idols but reminders of holy people and events. Catholics don’t worship these objects; they use them as aids to prayer and reflection. This practice is similar to how people might keep photos of loved ones. The Church teaches that worship is for God alone, and any seeming ‘worship’ of statues or images is actually veneration or respect, not worship.
Catholicism is just another Christian denomination
While Catholicism is a form of Christianity, it sees itself as the original Christian Church founded by Jesus. Catholics believe their Church has maintained an unbroken line of leadership from the apostles to today’s bishops and Pope. This doesn’t mean Catholics think other Christians aren’t ‘real’ Christians, but they do see their Church as uniquely established by Christ.
Catholics believe only Catholics go to heaven
The Catholic Church teaches that salvation is possible for people of all faiths and even for those with no faith. While the Church believes it offers the fullest means of salvation, it recognizes that God’s grace works in many ways. The Church teaches that those who sincerely seek God and follow their conscience can be saved, even if they never become Catholic.
The Catholic Church is wealthy and should sell its artwork
While the Vatican does have valuable artworks, most of the Church’s wealth is in property and buildings used for worship, education, and charity. The Church is one of the largest non-governmental providers of healthcare and education worldwide. Selling artwork would provide only temporary funds and would deprive future generations of cultural heritage. The Church sees itself as a steward of these artworks for all humanity.
Catholics must agree with the Church on every issue
While there are core beliefs that all Catholics are expected to hold, the Church recognizes that individual Catholics may disagree on many issues. The concept of ‘primacy of conscience’ teaches that Catholics must follow their well-formed conscience, even if it conflicts with Church teaching on non-core issues. However, Catholics are expected to seriously consider Church teachings when forming their conscience.
Catholic priests can forgive any sin
While priests can absolve sins in confession, they don’t have unlimited power to forgive. Some very serious sins, called ‘reserved sins,’ can only be absolved by the Pope or a bishop. Also, forgiveness requires true repentance from the person confessing. Priests provide absolution as representatives of God and the Church, not on their own authority. The Church teaches that it’s ultimately God who forgives sins.
Catholics believe in purgatory as a second chance after death
Purgatory, in Catholic teaching, is not a ‘second chance’ but a state of purification for those already saved. It’s seen as a process of becoming fully ready for heaven, not a place between heaven and hell. The Church teaches that choices for or against God are made in this life, not after death. Purgatory is for those who die in God’s friendship but still need purification.
The Catholic Church opposes all forms of birth control
While the Church does teach against artificial contraception, it supports natural family planning methods. The Church’s stance is based on its understanding of the purpose and nature of sexual intimacy, not on a desire to maximize births. The Church also recognizes that parents should be responsible for planning their families. However, the methods it approves are based on understanding and working with natural fertility cycles.
Catholics practice cannibalism in the Eucharist
Catholics believe that the bread and wine in the Eucharist truly become the body and blood of Christ, but this is a spiritual reality, not a physical one. The appearance and physical properties of the bread and wine remain unchanged. Catholics don’t see this as cannibalism but as a mystical participation in Christ’s sacrifice. This belief is based on Jesus’ words at the Last Supper and has been part of the Christian tradition from the earliest days.
The Catholic Church is against all abortion without exception
While the Church opposes direct abortion, it does allow for medical procedures that may result in the loss of the unborn child if the intent is to save the mother’s life. This is based on the principle of double effect. The Church’s position is more nuanced than a blanket ban, though it does place a high value on unborn life. The Church also emphasizes the need to support women in difficult pregnancies and after birth.
Catholics believe animals don’t have souls
The Catholic view on animal souls is more complex than a simple yes or no. The Church teaches that animals do have souls, but they are different from human souls. Animal souls are not believed to be immortal in the same way human souls are. The Church encourages kindness to animals and responsible stewardship of nature while maintaining that humans have a unique status in creation.
The Catholic Church is uniformly conservative or liberal
The Catholic Church’s positions don’t neatly fit into political categories of ‘conservative’ or ‘liberal.’ On some issues, like abortion or traditional marriage, the Church may be seen as conservative. On others, like immigration, care for the poor, or environmental protection, it may be viewed as liberal. The Church’s teachings are based on its understanding of human dignity and the common good, not on political ideologies.
17 Religious Beliefs That Are Questioned by Science
17 Religious Beliefs That Are Questioned by Science
15 Beliefs Boomers Hold Onto That Aren’t Relevant Today
15 Beliefs Boomers Hold Onto That Aren’t Relevant Today
15 Beliefs That Could Send You to Hell, According to the Bible
15 Beliefs That Could Send You to Hell, According to the Bible
