18 Things You Should Never Buy At a Thrift Store

Thrift stores are treasure troves for bargain hunters and eco-conscious shoppers. These secondhand shops offer various items at unbeatable prices, from vintage clothing to unique home decor. However, not everything you find at a thrift store is a smart buy. Some items can be unsafe, unsanitary, or simply not worth the money, even at discounted prices. I’ve compiled a list of 18 things you should think twice about before buying at a thrift store.

Mattresses

Image Credit: Stephen Andrews on Unsplash

Mattresses from thrift stores can harbor bed bugs, dust mites, and other allergens. These pests are hard to spot and even harder to get rid of. Old mattresses may also lack proper support, leading to poor sleep and back problems. It’s better to invest in a new mattress for your health and comfort.

Helmets

Image Credit: Mike Montgomery on Unsplash

Safety gear like helmets need to be in top condition to protect you. Thrift store helmets might have invisible damage from previous impacts. This damage can make them ineffective in case of an accident. Always buy new helmets to ensure your safety when biking, skateboarding, or doing other activities.

Car Seats

Image Credit: Patrick Konior on Unsplash

Child car seats have expiration dates and safety standards that change over time. Thrift store car seats might be outdated or damaged in ways you can’t see. Using an old or unsafe car seat puts your child at risk. It’s best to buy new car seats to keep your little ones safe during car rides.

Makeup and Cosmetics

Image Credit: Annie Spratt on Unsplash

Used makeup can spread bacteria and cause skin problems. Thrift store cosmetics might be expired or contaminated. Even if the makeup looks unused, it’s hard to know how long it’s been sitting on the shelf. Protect your skin by buying new makeup from trusted stores instead of risking infections from used products.

Stuffed Animals

Image Credit: Clarissa Watson on Unsplash

Stuffed toys from thrift stores can be full of dust, allergens, and even pests. These items are hard to clean thoroughly. Old stuffed animals might also have weak seams or small parts that could be dangerous for children. If you want a cuddly toy, it’s safer to buy a new one that you know is clean and safe.

Underwear

Image Credit: Fahad Waseem on Unsplash

Used underwear can spread bacteria and skin infections. Even if thrift store underwear looks clean, it’s hard to know how well it was washed. Buying new underwear is more hygienic and gives you peace of mind. Treat yourself to fresh, clean undergarments instead of risking your health with secondhand options.

Shoes

Image Credit: Patrick Hodskins on Unsplash

Shoes mold to the original owner’s feet over time. Wearing used shoes can cause foot pain, blisters, and other problems. Thrift store shoes might also have worn-out soles or damaged support. For your foot health and comfort, it’s better to buy new shoes that will fit your feet properly.

Cribs

Image Credit: Sven Brandsma on Unsplash

Baby cribs from thrift stores might not meet current safety standards. Old cribs can have design flaws that put babies at risk of injury or suffocation. Safety rules for cribs change often, so even a crib that looks fine might be unsafe. Protect your baby by buying a new crib that follows all the latest safety guidelines.

Nonstick Cookware

Image Credit: Murat Ts. on Unsplash

Scratched or peeling nonstick cookware can release harmful chemicals into your food. Thrift store pots and pans might have damaged coatings that you can’t see. Using these items could put your health at risk. It’s safer to buy new nonstick cookware or choose other types of pots and pans that last longer.

Swimwear

Image Credit: Christopher Campbell on Unsplash

Used swimwear can harbor bacteria, even after washing. The elastic in old swimsuits might be stretched out, making them less supportive and comfortable. Thrift store swimwear might also be faded or damaged from pool chemicals. Treat yourself to a new swimsuit that fits well and keeps you healthy in the water.

Hats

Image Credit: Onur Bahçıvancılar on Unsplash

Used hats can spread lice and skin problems. Thrift store hats might have absorbed sweat and oils from previous owners, making them hard to clean fully. The shape of used hats might also be altered, affecting how they fit and look. For hygiene and style, it’s better to buy new hats that you know are clean and shaped just for you.

Electrical Appliances

Brendan Stephens on Unsplash

Thrift store appliances might have hidden damage or missing parts. These issues can make the appliances unsafe to use, risking electrical fires or shocks. Old appliances might also use more energy, costing you more on your electric bill. For safety and efficiency, it’s smarter to buy new appliances or get them from trusted sources.

Tires

Image Credit: Carl Tronders on Unsplash

Used tires from thrift stores might have unseen damage or wear. Driving on unsafe tires can lead to accidents, especially in bad weather. It’s hard to know the full history of thrift store tires, including how they were stored. Your safety on the road is worth the cost of new tires from a reputable dealer.

Pillows

Image Credit: Maxim Mox on Unsplash

Old pillows can contain dust mites, dead skin cells, and other allergens. These build up over time and are hard to clean out completely. Thrift store pillows might also have lost their support, leading to neck pain and poor sleep. For better sleep and health, buy new, clean, and supportive pillows.

Baby Bottles

Image Credit: Jaye Haych on Unsplash

Used baby bottles might have scratches that can trap bacteria. The plastic in old bottles can also break down over time, releasing harmful chemicals. Thrift store bottles might be missing parts or use outdated designs that aren’t safe for babies. Keep your baby healthy by using new bottles that meet current safety standards.

Blenders and Food Processors

Image Credit: Andrea Niosi on Unsplash

These kitchen tools have many small parts that are hard to clean fully. Used blenders and food processors from thrift stores might have old food particles stuck in hard-to-reach places. This can lead to bacteria growth and food contamination. For safe and hygienic food prep, it’s best to buy these appliances new.

Sporting Goods

Image Credit: Cristina Anne Costello on Unsplash

Used sports equipment might have weak spots or damage you can’t see. This is especially true for items like tennis rackets, ski poles, or golf clubs. Using damaged gear can lead to poor performance or even injuries. Thrift store sports equipment might also be outdated, and missing key safety features. Invest in new gear to stay safe and perform your best.

Laptop Batteries

Image Credit: Mika Baumeister on Unsplash

Old laptop batteries can be unreliable or even dangerous. Thrift store laptops might have batteries that don’t hold a charge well or could overheat. In some cases, used batteries might even pose a fire risk. If you buy a used laptop, plan to replace the battery with a new one from a trusted source for safety and better performance.

12 Items Unsuitable for Dishwasher Use

Image Credit: Krystieyeo Yeo from Pixabay

12 Items Unsuitable for Dishwasher Use

17 Controversial Thieves and the Items They Stole

Image Credit: Jupi Lu from Pixabay

17 Controversial Thieves and the Items They Stole

Expectations vs. Reality: Truth About Millennials’ Spending Habits

Image Credit: Pavel Danilyuk on Pexels

Expectations vs. Reality: Truth About Millennials’ Spending Habits

Mary Apurong

Mary Apurong is an experienced writer and editor who enjoys researching topics related to lifestyle and creating content on gardening, food, travel, crafts, and DIY. She spends her free time doing digital art and watching documentaries. Check out some of her works on Mastermind Quotes.